Windows 11's Weather app eats 1GB of RAM to show you it's cloudy

4 min read 1 source clear_take
├── "Microsoft's WebView2-based first-party apps are a systemic resource problem, not a one-off bug"
│  └── Notebookcheck (Notebookcheck) → read

The article frames the Weather app's 1GB+ footprint as symptomatic of a broader Microsoft engineering pattern: shipping WebView2/Chromium shells around monetized web properties (News, Widgets, new Outlook, Copilot) rather than native apps. Each shell drags in a full browser engine, ad SDK, and telemetry, meaning a default Windows 11 install can burn 3-5GB of RAM on background web wrappers before the user opens anything.

├── "The memory bloat is driven by ads and monetization, not weather functionality"
│  └── Notebookcheck (Notebookcheck) → read

The reporter emphasizes that Weather is rendering microsoftnews.msn.com 'ads and all,' with tracking scripts and a preloading video player the user never requested. The implication is that the gigabyte isn't the cost of showing a forecast — it's the cost of running Microsoft's ad and content monetization stack inside what users assume is a utility app.

├── "Users should uninstall the stock app rather than wait for Microsoft to fix it"
│  ├── Notebookcheck (Notebookcheck) → read

With no fix in the Dev or Canary channels and no public comment from Microsoft, the article positions user-side removal as the only real remediation — specifically the PowerShell command to remove the BingWeather AppxPackage, or disabling the widget board that keeps the process warm. The framing treats the app as unsalvageable in its current form rather than something worth waiting on a patch for.

│  └── @akyuu (Hacker News, 581 pts) → view

By submitting the story to HN where it hit 581 points and 524 comments, the submitter amplified the remediation-focused framing to a technical audience that treats uninstalling default Microsoft apps as standard hygiene. The strong engagement suggests broad developer agreement that stock Windows apps like this shouldn't be tolerated on the system.

└── "The memory leak behavior — not just the baseline — is the real defect"
  └── Notebookcheck (Notebookcheck) → read

The article highlights that closing the Weather window doesn't release memory and that the working set continues to grow the longer the session runs. This reframes the story from 'bloated app' to 'leaking background process,' which is a categorically worse engineering failure than simply being heavyweight at launch.

What happened

Notebookcheck confirmed what a growing number of Windows 11 users have been posting screenshots of on Reddit and X: the stock Weather app that ships pinned to the Start menu is idling at over 1 GB of committed memory on typical machines. The report cites reproductions on multiple hardware configurations, including systems with modest 8 GB total RAM where the app alone accounts for more than 12% of everything the machine has.

Closing the Weather window does not release the memory — the app keeps a background process alive, and Task Manager shows the working set continuing to grow the longer the session runs. Under the hood, Weather is not a native Win32 or even a proper WinUI app. It's a WebView2 shell rendering `microsoftnews.msn.com` content, ads and all, with the same Chromium engine that powers Edge. The reporter noted the app also pulls in tracking scripts and a video player that appears to preload content the user never asked for.

Microsoft has not commented publicly on the specific number, and there's no fix flighting in the Dev or Canary channels as of writing. The only remediation available to users today is uninstalling the app via `Get-AppxPackage *BingWeather* | Remove-AppxPackage` or disabling the widget board that keeps it warm.

Why it matters

A gigabyte for a weather forecast would be a punchline if it weren't a pattern. The Weather app is one of a growing catalog of first-party Windows apps — News, Widgets, the new Outlook, Copilot, even parts of the Start menu search — that are WebView2 shells wrapped around web properties Microsoft also monetizes. Each one carries the full weight of a browser engine, a Node-style JavaScript runtime, an ad SDK, and telemetry. Multiply that across the four or five that a default install runs, and you're looking at 3–5 GB of RAM burned before the user opens anything.

The engineering trade is obvious from Redmond's side: one codebase ships to the web, to Windows, to Xbox, to the Edge sidebar. The team that owns msn.com owns the Weather app. Native code is expensive; WebView2 is free. But the cost gets pushed onto the customer's hardware, and it compounds. Chrome, Slack, Teams (also WebView-based), Discord, and VS Code each carry their own Chromium. A machine running a normal developer workload can easily have six or seven independent Chromium instances resident, none of which share memory pages, because Microsoft never delivered on the promise of a shared WebView2 runtime pool that early docs implied.

The community reaction on Hacker News landed hard on one point: this is what happens when the OS vendor is also an ad network. The Weather app doesn't need 1 GB to show the temperature. It needs 1 GB because it's rendering the same monetized surface as the MSN homepage, and the OS shell is the delivery vehicle. Comparisons flew to KDE's Plasma weather widget (~15 MB), macOS's Weather app (~80 MB, and it's a full SwiftUI app with animations), and even the old Windows 7 gadget (single-digit MB). The gap isn't 10x. It's 100x.

There's also a security angle worth naming. A background WebView2 instance loading third-party ad JavaScript is, by definition, an unsandboxed remote code execution surface running with the user's privileges — and Microsoft has already had to patch WebView2 CVEs this year. The Weather app is not a weather app. It's a persistent, always-on browser tab loading ad-tech from partners the user never chose to trust, on the OS's dime.

What this means for your stack

If you're shipping a desktop app in 2026 and reaching for Electron, Tauri, or WebView2 by default, this is the cautionary tale. The abstraction is only free until users notice — and Task Manager has made memory usage the most public performance benchmark on the planet. Tauri (Rust + system webview) has been eating Electron's lunch precisely because a lot of teams looked at their idle RAM footprint and got embarrassed. Windows itself doing the wrong thing here doesn't excuse anyone else.

For ops and IT teams managing Windows fleets, the practical move is to strip the AppX bloat during imaging. A one-liner in your provisioning script:

```powershell Get-AppxPackage -AllUsers *BingWeather*, *BingNews*, *MicrosoftNews*, *GetHelp*, *Getstarted* | Remove-AppxPackage -AllUsers ```

Disabling the Widgets board (`Settings → Personalization → Taskbar`) kills the other big offender. Neither is supported long-term — Microsoft has a habit of reinstalling these on feature updates — so bake it into your golden image and re-run on 24H2 → 25H2 upgrades.

For developers building on WebView2 specifically, the takeaway is to treat it like a container, not a component. Ship your own bundled ad-free content, lazy-load anything remote, tear down the WebView when the window closes rather than keeping it warm for perceived responsiveness, and measure private working set — not just heap — in your CI perf gates. The default settings will bleed memory.

Looking ahead

Microsoft will almost certainly ship a fix — the story is embarrassing enough — but the underlying architecture won't change. Weather will get lighter; the next MSN-backed shell will bloat back to fill the space. The interesting question is whether users start noticing the pattern in aggregate, and whether that translates into pressure on Windows to publish per-app memory budgets the way iOS quietly enforces them. Until then, the cheapest 8 GB machine Microsoft is happy to certify for Windows 11 is running an OS whose stock apps assume you have 32.

Hacker News 594 pts 536 comments

Windows 11's built-in Weather app wastes more than 1 GB of RAM

→ read on Hacker News
ndriscoll · Hacker News

My gaming PC that I built in January 2006 that IIRC I used to simultaneously run Battlefield 2, Trillian, Xfire, Thunderbird, and Winamp with a 1680x1050 monitor had 1 GB of total system RAM.

GuB-42 · Hacker News

Putting aside the fact that it is horribly bloated. Accurately measuring RAM usage is tricky, there are several measurements, and no "right" one.It is clear from the article that what eats up so much RAM is not the weather app itself but the framework it runs on. There is a "Renderer&

daemin · Hacker News

I checked this on my computers:On Windows 10 the Weather application uses 2-4MB when not active, which climbs to around 490-550MB when active. On Windows 11 the Weather application doesn't appear to be running at all when not active and it climbs to about 540MB when active.No where near the res

SBArbeit · Hacker News

Easy workaround for this:1. Install uBlock Origin in Edge.2. Start Edge, browse to MSN Weather.3. Click the "Add an Application" button in the address bar to get a Start Menu icon for the page.4. Delete the in-box Weather app icon.Now you get the same Weather app in about 130MB of RAM, wit

dzonga · Hacker News

technically web apps should be light as air.but complexity merchants make them weight as much as the sun.

// share this

// get daily digest

Top 10 dev stories every morning at 8am UTC. AI-curated. Retro terminal HTML email.